Current:Home > StocksOhio embraced the ‘science of reading.’ Now a popular reading program is suing-LoTradeCoin
Ohio embraced the ‘science of reading.’ Now a popular reading program is suing
View Date:2024-12-23 20:22:32
COLUMBUS, Ohio (AP) — The battle over how to teach reading has landed in court.
With momentum shifting in favor of research-backed strategies known as the “science of reading,” states and some school districts have been ditching once popular programs amid concerns that they aren’t effective.
A legal fight in Ohio centers on a state ban of material that uses a common technique called three-cueing. It involves encouraging students to draw on meaning, sentence structure and visual clues to identify words, asking questions like: “What is going to happen next?,” “What is the first letter of the word?” or “What clues do the pictures offer?”
The technique is a key part of the Reading Recovery program used in more than 2,400 U.S. elementary schools. The Reading Recovery Council of North America filed a lawsuit earlier this month, saying lawmakers infringed on the powers of state and local education boards by using a budget bill to ban three-cueing.
Ohio Gov. Mike DeWine, a Republican, blasted the lawsuit, calling evidence in favor of the science of reading “abundantly clear.”
“Now we have a lawsuit being filed by people who just want to make money,” he told reporters this week. “They’re upset that they’re not going to be able to make money anymore. They don’t care about kids, and I think Ohioans ought to be very angry about that type of a lawsuit.”
The Reading Recovery Council, the nonprofit that operates the program, didn’t immediately respond to a message seeking comment. But it said on the platform formerly known as Twitter that it will fight for evidence-based reading instruction “as defined by educators and researchers, not politicians and corporate interests.”
Proponents of the science of reading argue students need detailed instruction on the building blocks of reading. The push was led by parents of children with dyslexia, who need systematic instruction to read. It gained steam during the pandemic as schools looked for ways to regain ground lost during the pandemic.
Reading Recovery is not the only program to find itself on the outs.
Last month, the Columbia University’s Teachers College announced it was shutting down a reading program that also employed three-cueing and was founded by education guru Lucy Calkins.
Once used in hundreds of New York City public schools and thousands of others nationwide, Calkins’ “Units of Study” found itself facing scrutiny. Calkins added more phonics to appease her critics, but it was too late.
New York City, whose mayor often talks about his personal struggle with dyslexia, dropped her program. And several other states, including Arkansas, Louisiana and Virginia, have banned schools from using methods based on three-cueing.
Mike McGovern, president of the International Dyslexia Association of Central Ohio, said his organization is behind the governor in the legal fight.
“It’s about money,” he said, of the lawsuit. “Like any business they have to fight back.”
In Ohio, the latest state operating budget bill stipulates that by the next school year, all schools must use reading programs that have been approved by the state.
In its lawsuit, the Worthington, Ohio-based Reading Recovery Council of North America argued a budget bill cannot set policy. Under the state’s constitution, that role is left to the state Board of Education — some of whose members also have sued the state over budget provisions that restructure the state’s Education Department and curtail their authority.
Under the state law, which the suit describes as “contradictory, and indecipherable,” the only time three-cuing is allowed is if a district get a waiver or the approach is part of a student’s special education plan.
One recent blow to the program is a federally funded study that found students who received the program’s intensive one-on-one help as struggling first-graders had lower test scores years later than a similar cohort that didn’t participate.
The study’s lead author, Henry May, said he was “flabbergasted” by the result.
“From an evaluation perspective, what that means to me is, in the long term, the program is potentially harmful,” said May, director of the Center for Research in Education and Social Policy at the University of Delaware.
The main problem is that three-cueing emphasizes using clues besides the actual spelling of a word, creating problems once students don’t have pictures to help, said Jill Allor, an education professor at Southern Methodist University in Dallas. She said older students then have to unlearn the habit of guessing.
“It is just inconsistent,” she said, “with the science behind how reading develops and also the evidence about which programs are the most effective.”
___
Hollingsworth reported from Mission, Kansas.
___
The Associated Press education team receives support from the Carnegie Corporation of New York. The AP is solely responsible for all content.
veryGood! (31)
Related
- Record-setting dry conditions threaten more US wildfires, drinking water supplies
- Alabama seeks to perform second execution using nitrogen hypoxia
- New York AG says she’ll seize Donald Trump’s property if he can’t pay $454 million civil fraud debt
- Machine Gun Kelly Shares Heartbreaking Message on Megan Fox’s Miscarriage
- 'Serial swatter': 18-year-old pleads guilty to making nearly 400 bomb threats, mass shooting calls
- Charges against alleged white supremacists are tossed by a California judge for the second time
- Leaked document trove shows a Chinese hacking scheme focused on harassing dissidents
- This Lionel Messi dribble over an injured player went viral on TikTok
- Utah AD Mark Harlan rips officials following loss to BYU, claims game was 'stolen from us'
- HIV/AIDS activist Hydeia Broadbent, known for her inspirational talks as a young child, dies at 39
Ranking
- John Krasinski named People magazine’s 2024 Sexiest Man Alive
- Insulin prices were capped for millions. But many still struggle to afford to life-saving medication
- 'Avatar: The Last Airbender': Release date, cast, where to watch live-action series
- A Missouri woman was killed in 1989. Three men are now charged in the crime
- Kelly Rowland and Nelly Reunite for Iconic Performance of Dilemma 2 Decades Later
- ‘Little dark secret': DEA agent on trial accused of taking $250K in bribes from Mafia
- Mischa Barton confirms she dated 'The O.C.' co-star Ben McKenzie
- Two steps forward, one step back: NFL will have zero non-white offensive coordinators
Recommendation
-
Rare Alo Yoga Flash Sale: Don’t Miss 60% Off Deals With Styles as Low as $5
-
In wake of mass shooting, here is how Maine’s governor wants to tackle gun control and mental health
-
AT&T’s network is down, here’s what to do when your phone service has an outage
-
Kodak Black released from jail after drug possession charge dismissed
-
Gun groups sue to overturn Maine’s new three-day waiting period to buy firearms
-
A Texas deputy was killed and another injured in a crash while transporting an inmate, sheriff says
-
Robert Port, who led AP investigative team that won Pulitzer for No Gun Ri massacre probe, dies
-
Curb your Messi Mania expectations in 2024. He wants to play every match, but will he?